Custom Softball Trading Pins

Endless Customization

Unique shapes, sizes, and your choice of a cool pin upgrades ensures a memorable pin.

Superior Craftsmanship

Hand-crafted using high quality materials, our pins are both stunning to look at and durable.

World-Class Art Team

Your design will be completely custom and created by one of our talented US-based artists.

Free Shipping

Shipping to the United States and Canada through FedEx or UPS is included in our quotes.


Our Pricing Includes The Following

Free Digital Proof – With a little information, we’ll create a unique design that is sure to be the talk of the tournament.  No design skills are necessary. Just send over logos, photos, websites, social media, or even a sketch on a napkin. Our talented artists can work off just about anything. The design you receive from us will be 100% custom to your team.

Unlimited Revisions – It can be tough to nail down a design that makes everyone on the team happy. That’s why we’re happy to make unlimited revisions for you. Whether it’s starting all over or just swapping a color around, we’re more than happy to work together to create a memorable pin.

US-Based Artists – Most pin companies outsource their art and recycle old designs. Not Custom Comet. Our team of artists based in the United States have decades of experience designing sports trading pins. They understand what is popular have created pins for hundreds of different tournaments.

Stunning Colors – High-quality enamel paint is used to produce vibrant colors that will stand out amongst the crowd. With 1,867 solid-coated Pantone colors at our disposal, there is no doubt we can match your softball team’s look and feel.

Expert Craftsmanship – We would put the quality of our trading pins up against anyone in the industry. Our factory has decades of experience making trading pins and are at the forefront of new manufacturing methods. Your team has worked hard to get where it is and deserves that same hard work out of your pin company.

Transparent Pricing – We like to say “what you see is what you pay”. Our pricing includes everything from mold costs, shipping, and even taxes (as a Portland company, there is no sales tax). Please note that with some complex pins, we may not be able to provide you an accurate quote until a design has been created. But we will be transparent through the process.

Free Shipping – All orders ship free to the United States and Canada using either FedEx or UPS. While packages typically arrive in 3-5 business days, we recommend leaving added time on in case of unforeseen delays by the carrier.

Your Softball Pins Are Fully Customizable

Our trading pins are fully customizable. We offer pin types, thousands of color choices, and an array of metal finishes. Even the backs of our pins can be customized.

Below are just some of the options available to you. If there is something special you’d like to try, please don’t hesitate to ask. We love new ideas and can create just about anything.

Pin Types – We offer soft enamel, hard enamel, and offset printed pins. While soft enamel is the de-facto choice for teams, offset printed pins are an alternative for those in a rush or needing to show shadows and gradients in their art. Hard enamel provides a classier look that is a great choice for tournament staff or umpires.

Pin Upgrades – Adding some bling is a great way to stand out from the crowd. We offer blinkers, bobbleheads, crystals, danglers, puzzle pins, sliders, spinners, and more. Add some glitter to your pins to make it shine or use our glow-in-the-dark paint for a really cool effect.

Choice of Backers – Utilize not just the front, but the back of your pins. We offer the choice of colorful rubber backers to accentuate your design. Or for a classier look, go with the classic metal butterfly clasps.

Limited Edition Pins – Build a limited edition version of your pins for those special trades. This can be done by changing the colors or design. A great way to increase the trade value of some pins. Not sure how? Just ask our pin experts to help.

Still have questions? You may find our FAQ helpful. And of course, you can reach fill out our quote for or us our contact us page. We offer e-mail, text, and phone support.

Pin Enhancements



Starting at $0.10 per pin.

Soccer ball as a Spinner


Starting at $0.59 per pin.

Blinker trading pin


Starting at $0.99 per pin.

Crystal add-on


Starting at $0.10 per pin.

Glow In the Dark


Starting at $0.15 per pin.

Puzzle Pin

& Much More


Some frequently asked questions about our softball pins.

100 pieces. We can make exceptions in certain circumstances.

Filling out our quote form is a great way to get started. We ask for some information on the pins you’re looking for and about your team (websites, social media, etc). The includes uploading any logos, photos, or even something sketched on paper. We’ll do our best to work from that information to provide you a proof to start from.

And if you’re completely lost about what to get, no worries, our team has decades of experience designing pins. We are happy to answer any and all questions and can point you in the direction of what you may need for a particular tournament.

Getting all the players and parents on the same page of a design can be a monumental task for you. This is why we are happy to offer unlimited revisions to your design till we’ve created something your team loves.

Don’t be shy either, it’s part of the process. Sometimes you need to see how a design looks with a different color, and sometimes it’s best to just scrap it and start fresh. Whatever you’re looking at, our talented art team is ready to work for you.

We recommend starting at 1.5″ and working your way up depending on the design. Pins listing player names or numbers typically need to be closer to 2″ in size. And tournaments such as Cooperstown tend to gravitate to large pins.

Trading pins are meant to standout and the larger pins tend to have higher trade values. You are better off ordering a smaller number of large pins as opposed to higher quantity of small pins.

And as always, if you’re not sure what size to get, we’re more than happy to help find a solution to meet your budget.

We recommend that each player have one pin for each team participating in the tournament. At the very least, you’ll want one pin for each team you play.

One thing to keep in mind is that pin trading is for everyone. Parents, siblings, and even umpires participate in the fun. So ordering some extras just in case is always a great idea. Since price per pin drops with higher quantities, the more you order, the more you save.

Soft enamel is the de-facto choice for travel softball teams. They are comprised of a thick metal base that is typically iron although sometimes zinc is used to protect thinner parts that may break off. Edges are raised and filled in with enamel paint and left to dry. Soft enamel pins have a textured feel and high-quality look.

Offset-printed pins take a solid metal base and then print your design on to them. They are then capped with an epoxy top to provide protection from scratches. The ability to print directly to the metal allows for more complex designs that utilize shadows or gradients. They also take less time to produce and cost less than their soft enamel counterparts.

Absolutely! Just fill out our quick-and-easy quote form and we’ll get back to you within 1 business day (usually sooner).

None! The price we quote is what you pay. Our quotes include free shipping and as an Oregon business, there is no sales tax.

Our pins are currently manufactured at our factory in China. They have decades of experience creating pins and the most stringent standards in place to ensure a quality product.

At Custom Comet, we try our best to manufacture everything we can in the United States. However, certain products are just not possible due to overwhelming costs. To produce pins of this quality in the United States, the price would 3-4 times as much.

Almost every maker of trading pins imports from China. While there are companies that offer US-made pins, they are considerably lower quality (more of a button than a pin) and only recommended for last-minute purchases.

On average, trading pins take 3 weeks to manufacture and another week to ship. All orders ship via FedEx or UPS.

When you receive a quote from us, we will inform you of the last possible date you can place an order to expect your pins to arrive on time.

Please note that shipping delays can occur. We highly recommend ordering your pins at the earliest possible date to provide some added cushion. You have enough stress to deal with heading off to a tournament and waiting on a last-minute delivery should not be one of them.

We currently do not offer a rush option at this time. Pins are made in the order they are received.

Custom Comet is based out of Portland, Oregon. Our offices are at Watershed PDX. We can provide samples and local pick-up through our pick-up window upon request.

Why Choose Custom Comet?

Recent Articles

Soft Enamel vs Hard Enamel Pins

Enamel pins are a great way to share your art, support a cause, or create brand awareness for your business. Choosing the right style of ...
Pin Backer Card

Pin Backer Cards: What Are They and How to Use Them

You’ve created your design, decided which pin style works, and chosen the add-ons that fit your aesthetic. Now it’s time to think about the presentation ...
Merrowed Edge vs Hot Cut Edge

Merrowed Edge vs Hot Cut Edge: Which Patch is Right For You?

When designing a custom patch as an artist or a company, the importance is in the details. A detail worth mentioning is the border of ...

Evolution of the Coffee Sleeve

The 1990’s spurned a coffee revolution of sorts across America. Shops began to pop up on every corner while the demand for higher quality beans ...

History of Trading Pins

For Little League Baseball and other youth sports, trading pins have become as ubiquitous to the events as the games themselves. Parents proudly display the ...

8 Businesses That Can Benefit From Custom Air Fresheners

  The auto air freshener has been a part of our culture since Magic Tree invented them in 1952. Dangling from the rearview mirror, they ...

100% Satisfaction Guarantee!

You can order with 100% confidence from Custom Comet. All our products are quality checked during and after manufacture. In the unlikely event your products arrive with a defect or fault, just get in touch and we will swiftly put things right. For full details see our guarantee page.

The Sky's The Limit

Not sure what you need?

It’s never too early to talk to us. If you aren’t sure which product to go for, or what sort of design you want just email us at, use the live chat or give us a call 1-888-684-2933. We’re here to help with ideas and advice, and we’re on hand to answer any questions, Monday through Friday from 7am to 4pm PST